AsphaltTons.com — asphalt tonnage calculator

23A Gravel: When Michigan Uses It and How Many Tons

23A gravel is the Michigan Department of Transportation's dense-graded surface gravel: the pile you want when a road, shoulder or driveway is going to stay gravel, not get paved. The "23" is just the class number in MDOT's aggregate table. The important part is the fines. 23A is allowed to have roughly twice the material passing the No. 200 sieve as the 21- and 22-series bases, because those fines, often a little clay, are what bind a gravel surface so it doesn't stay loose under tires.

Estimate your 23A tons in the gravel calculator →

What 23A gravel is

Section 902.05 of MDOT's 2020 Standard Specifications for Construction (with errata through April 30, 2025) lists five dense-graded classes for bases, surfaces, shoulders, approaches and patching: 21AA, 21A, 22A, 23A and 23AA. "Dense-graded" means the stone is sized from coarse down to dust so the smaller particles fill the voids. Pits sell 23A as natural gravel, crushed limestone or a blend, and the spec also allows iron blast-furnace slag, reverberatory furnace slag or crushed concrete. If 23A is made from steel-furnace slag, MDOT allows it only as an unbound surface course or unbound shoulder, not under pavement. Most residential loads are gravel or limestone.

On MDOT work, crushed concrete is barred within 100 feet of a stream, river, county drain or lake, and dense-graded recycled concrete may not contain more than 5.0% building rubble or HMA by particle count. Lapeer County's January 17, 2022 residential approach sheet still allows crushed concrete or HMA millings in the right of way, but nothing larger than 1½ inches and no brick, wire, glass, wood or rubber. If a pit offers recycled 23A, ask what is in the pile and where it will be placed.

The sieve numbers that make it 23A

MDOT Table 902-1 (MTM 109 sieves, MTM 108 loss by washing, dry weights) is short for 23A. It has no 1½-inch or ½-inch column, and unlike 22A gravel it has no ¾-inch requirement. Everything must pass the 1-inch sieve, and then three bands matter:

Class1 in¾ in⅜ inNo. 8LBW (No. 200)
21AA / 21A85–100—50–75 (at ½ in)20–454–8
22A10090–10065–8530–504–8
23A / 23AA100—60–8525–609–16
  • The top size is 1 inch. Everything has to pass the 1-inch sieve, the same cap as 22A and tighter than 21A / 21AA, which can keep 1½-inch stone. That smaller top size is easier on blades and windshields.
  • The mid-size band is wide. 60–85% must pass the ⅜-inch sieve, and 25–60% must pass the No. 8. 22A is tighter on the No. 8 (30–50%) and also requires 90–100% to pass ¾ inch.
  • The fines are the point. Loss by washing on 23A and 23AA is 9–16%, reported to the nearest whole percent (footnote (e) in Table 902-1). 21A, 21AA and 22A are limited to 4–8%. That extra silt-and-clay fraction is what MDOT wants in a surface gravel, and what it does not want under a pavement.

Table 902-2 sets toughness: 23A needs at least 25% crushed particles (MTM 117) and an LA abrasion loss of no more than 50% (MTM 102). 23AA uses the same gradation and abrasion limit but raises crushed content to 95%. For 23A limestone, footnote (l) also caps insoluble residue finer than the No. 200 sieve at 10% (MTM 103).

23A vs 22A: which one should you order?

MDOT answers this by use, not by marketing name. Section 306, Aggregate Surface Course and Maintenance Gravel, is blunt: if the surface will later be paved, provide 21A, 21AA or 22A; if it will stay gravel, provide 23A or 23AA. Temporary maintenance gravel can be any of those five classes, or salvaged aggregate.

Section 307, Aggregate Shoulders and Approaches, maps the classes onto shoulder classes:

  • Class I: 22A, or 21A / 21AA / 22A if that Class I area will be paved.
  • Class II: 23A or 23AA.
  • Class III: salvaged aggregate, 23A or 23AA.
  • Class IV: existing shoulder material.

The Road Design Manual, section 6.02.09B, explains why. Soil binder (clay) is added to a driving surface so it is denser and less loose under traffic; that binder does not add much load-carrying capacity. In a base course the same binder slows drainage and is susceptible to frost heave. Section 6.02.09C warns that substituting a base gravel for a surface gravel is usually acceptable, but "it is less desirable to substitute surface course for base course." If you might pave the lane in a year or two, start with 22A or 21AA, not 23A.

Don't mix this up with 21A gravel from another state: Virginia's 21A is a VDOT base stone, while Michigan 21A / 21AA is the coarser class in Table 902-1.

Where you will actually see 23A on the ground

MDOT itself rarely builds a permanent gravel road. Road Design Manual section 6.02.09A says an HMA surface is the Department's minimum, and aggregate surface course is used only occasionally, for a park-and-ride lot, a county-road relocation or a long local-road approach. County road commissions are a different story. They buy 23A, especially 23A limestone, in quantity for gravel-road resurfacing and shoulders.

Ionia County's Road Department advertised Contract 25-13 in January 2025 to furnish and haul 23A limestone meeting current MDOT specifications. That is a typical county use: limestone 23A placed as a wearing surface on a gravel road and bladed through the year. Our gravel road maintenance guide covers the crown, moisture and drainage that keep a surface like that from washboarding.

Some counties also accept 23A in a residential driveway approach. The Lapeer County Road Commission sheet allows MDOT 21AA, 22A or 23A, at least 8 inches deep, with a 2% minimum slope down and away from the road shoulder. Culverts must be at least 30 feet long, with a 3:1 slope from the aggregate edge down to the pipe and no vertical headwalls. Those are Lapeer's right-of-way rules, not a statewide driveway code, but 8 inches and a definite slope are a sound pattern.

How much does a yard of 23A weigh?

MDOT does not publish a 23A-only unit weight. Road Design Manual section 6.02.04 gives a planning number for compacted aggregates in general: 4,000 pounds per cubic yard, or 2.0 tons. Section 6.02.08 lists approximate compacted unit weights of 148 lb/ft³ for natural aggregate, 144 lb/ft³ for blast-furnace slag and 184 lb/ft³ for steel-furnace slag. The natural-aggregate figure times 27 cubic feet per yard is 3,996 pounds, or 2.00 tons, the same planning number. Steel-furnace slag would be heavier: 184 lb/ft³ times 27 is about 4,970 pounds, or roughly 2.5 tons per compacted cubic yard, so do not use the 2.0-ton figure on a slag ticket. For ordinary natural or limestone 23A, plan on 2.0 tons per compacted cubic yard, then confirm with the pit.

Pits often sell by the loose ton or the loose yard, not the compacted yard your thickness calculation describes. Loose volume in the truck is larger than the compacted volume on the grade. If the price is per loose yard, you will need more yards than the compacted figure; if the price is per ton, the 2.0 ton-per-compacted-yard planning weight is the one that lines up with a takeoff.

Quick table: tons of 23A per 100 square feet

These figures use MDOT's 2.0 ton-per-compacted-yard planning weight for natural aggregate. They are estimates, not a pay quantity.

Compacted depthCubic yardsTons at 2.0 t/yd³
4 in1.232.5
6 in1.853.7
8 in2.474.9

Worked example: a 14-by-200-foot farm lane

Say you want a new 14-foot-wide farm lane, 200 feet long, compacted 8 inches deep in 23A. That depth matches Lapeer's minimum for a gravel approach and is a reasonable starting thickness for farm traffic, not a statewide rule for private property.

Walk the length with a Zozen measuring wheel and measure the average width, then convert to compacted cubic yards:

14 × 200 = 2,800 square feet. Times 8/12 foot of depth = 1,866.7 cubic feet. Divide by 27: 69.1 compacted cubic yards. At MDOT's 2.0 tons per compacted cubic yard, that is 138 tons of natural or limestone 23A.

A shorter residential driveway is easier to picture. A 12-by-80-foot drive at the same 8-inch depth is 23.7 compacted cubic yards, or about 47 tons at 2.0 tons per yard. If the subgrade is soft clay, a Super Geotextile woven driveway fabric (12.5 × 60 ft) under the first lift can keep the 23A from punching into the soil; that is a separation layer, not a substitute for thickness.

Order from that tonnage, then add only what the pit and the trucker say you need for waste, flares and a turnout. Confirm whether the price is per ton or per loose yard, and whether the stone is natural gravel, limestone or slag, before you lock in the load count.

How 23A gets placed and compacted

Section 306 sets the construction rules for an aggregate surface course. Do not place the material on an unstable surface. Spread it in compacted layers no thicker than 8 inches. If an HMA surface is going on later, each layer has to reach at least 98% of the maximum unit weight at no greater than optimum moisture; for a surface that will stay gravel, the requirement is 95%. The finished surface, and each layer, has to come in within ±½ inch of the plan crown and grade. Additives are allowed for compaction and dust control.

On a Class II or Class III shoulder or approach, Section 307 also requires 95% of maximum unit weight at no greater than optimum moisture, except for layers 3 inches or less. A layer thinner than 3 inches has to be keyed in by scarifying 2 inches of the layer below. Do not place the stone on frozen, soft, unstable or rutted subgrade, and grade it so water sheds off the shoulder.

On a residential lane the same ideas hold, even if nobody is running a density gauge. Keep the stone damp enough to bind, compact each lift, and work the edges. A walk-behind roller or plate compactor is the right tool for a driveway; in tight corners a Estwing 10 × 10 in steel tamper will finish around a culvert or garage apron. Use Lapeer's 2% minimum slope at the approach, and farther up the lane a modest crown that drains to both ditches, so the 23A does not rut into a trough.

Tickets, moisture and getting the stone there

On an MDOT surface-course job, every load needs a ticket with the project number, aggregate source, series (this is where "23A" should be printed), date, time, truck identifier, supplier name and type of aggregate approval. Weight tickets also show gross, tare and net to the nearest 100 pounds, with the tare taken at least once a day. If moisture tests over 8%, the Engineer deducts the excess from the scale weight (Sections 306 and 307). That is why a wet spring load can weigh more than the compacted tons you planned.

If you are hauling in late winter or early spring, check Michigan's frost laws before you schedule trucks. Seasonal axle-weight cuts shrink what a tandem or tri-axle may carry on county roads, which changes how many loads 138 tons will take. Our frost laws guide walks through the spring limits.

23A gravel FAQ

What is 23A gravel?

23A is MDOT's dense-graded surface gravel for roads, shoulders and driveways that will stay unpaved. It is graded to a 1-inch top size with 9–16% loss by washing, more fines than 22A, so the surface binds under traffic.

What is the difference between 23A and 22A?

Section 306 assigns 22A, 21A or 21AA to aggregate surfaces that will later be paved, and 23A or 23AA to surfaces that will stay gravel. 22A is limited to 4–8% loss by washing; 23A allows 9–16%. If you plan to pave, start with 22A or 21AA, not 23A.

What is 23AA gravel?

23AA has the same sieve limits as 23A but must be at least 95% crushed particles instead of 25%. It is the crushed-content upgrade, the same idea as 21AA versus 21A.

How many tons of 23A are in a cubic yard?

MDOT's planning weight for compacted aggregates is 4,000 pounds per cubic yard, or 2.0 tons, which matches the 148 lb/ft³ natural-aggregate figure in the Road Design Manual. Steel-furnace slag 23A is heavier, about 2.5 tons per compacted yard. Confirm the number with the pit.

How thick should a 23A driveway be?

Lapeer County requires at least 8 inches of 21AA, 22A or 23A in a residential gravel approach. That is a county right-of-way minimum, not a statewide private-driveway rule, but 8 inches compacted, in lifts no thicker than 8 inches and sloped to drain, is a sound starting point.

The bottom line

Order 23A when the surface will stay gravel, and 22A or 21AA when you plan to pave. The class is a 1-inch top size, a wide mid-size band, and 9–16% loss by washing, with a 25% crushed minimum for 23A and 95% for 23AA. Plan on 2.0 tons per compacted cubic yard for natural or limestone 23A, then confirm with the pit. An 8-inch, 14-by-200-foot lane is about 69 compacted cubic yards, or about 138 tons. Compact it in lifts no thicker than 8 inches, keep water off the surface, and do not treat 23A as a base for tomorrow's asphalt.

Sources

As an Amazon Associate, AsphaltTons.com earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below are sponsored.